Rimmel Extra Super Lash Mascara Black Reviews

Reviews

Suzanne (Tomah)

Home Tester
36 Reviews

Suzanne (Tomah)

Home Tester
36 Reviews
0 Upload

15/02/2025

Smears

This mascara coats really thick and doesn't seem to ever dry fully so it smears all over the place.

Heather (Brooklyn)

Home Tester
112 Reviews

Heather (Brooklyn)

Home Tester
112 Reviews
0 Upload

08/02/2025

Clumpy But Cute?

I have used other Rimmel products & enjoyed them so when I saw this discounted I thought I would give it a try. I like a little bit of a clumpy look but that’s a very personal preference so if you don’t this definitely isn’t the mascara for you! It’s a bit dry from the first use but again, I like that as I typically don’t love mascara the first few applications of a new tube. It definitely gave my skimpy lashes some extra volume & it’s very dark, carbon black. I like it but it’s definitely not the best mascara I have used by a long shot.

Nabeel (Oaklawn)

855 Reviews

+20

Nabeel (Oaklawn)

855 Reviews
0 Upload

+20

01/02/2025

I won't buy again

I do not know, I cannot find anything special in it, I did not like it, it does not work to prolong and intensify the freckles .. Everyone has their taste different

Theresa (Festus)

Home Tester
48 Reviews

Theresa (Festus)

Home Tester
48 Reviews
0 Upload

19/07/2024

Not impressed

Sadly I was not impressed by this mascara. It didn't do much and the little it did didn't last. I would not buy it again.

Victoria (San Francisco)

Home Tester Pro
350 Reviews

Victoria (San Francisco)

Home Tester Pro
350 Reviews
0 Upload

18/07/2024

Not very good

I bought this Rimmel mascara because it was a good deal for 2 tubes, but now that I have tried it,I am fairly sure that I will never repurchase it. It's just not very good. It's dry, and not thin enough, so it immediately looks clumpy and lumpy, instead of long and feathery. It's not a good deal if you hate every minute of using it.

Danielle (Grundy)

Home Tester
4 Reviews

Danielle (Grundy)

Home Tester
4 Reviews
0 Upload

26/04/2024

good mascara

I really like this mascara , it goes on easy and it doesn't smudge or flake and when I take it off it comes off easy .

Brett (Weldon)

Home Tester
15 Reviews

Brett (Weldon)

Home Tester
15 Reviews
0 Upload

05/04/2024

Great budget buy

I was actually surprised by this mascara. The brush coats lashes individually the formula is Not clumpy at all, it's a thin easily applied formula. Great highly pigmented color. Easy to apply no drag or pulling. Cons it does tend to start flaking off at around 5 hours.

Kayla (Hayward)

Home Tester Ace
305 Reviews

Kayla (Hayward)

Home Tester Ace
305 Reviews
0 Upload

21/03/2024

I didn’t love

It was pretty clumpy. I have long lashes. I think if you have long lashes you will not like this mascara. The wand was a bit too unforgiving and somehow I smudged a lot and normally I’m pretty ok.

Akankshya (Schaumburg)

38 Reviews

Akankshya (Schaumburg)

38 Reviews
0 Upload

27/02/2024

AMAZING MASCARA

I swear by this product! This was my first mascara purchase when I started makeup years and years ago and I still go back to it! It elongate my lashes and is very easy to remove! Works wonders! It’s also beginner friendly

Abby (Decatur)

Home Tester
29 Reviews

Abby (Decatur)

Home Tester
29 Reviews
0 Upload

22/02/2024

My Favorite Mascara

I’ve used this mascara for years and it never disappoints. Not only is it affordable, it lengthens and defines my lashes beautifully. It’s buildable and doesn’t flake or irritate my contact lenses, plus it’s easy to remove without lash loss. I’ve tried so many different mascaras but always come back to this Rommel staple because it delivers every single time.

Kristy (Hitchcock)

8 Reviews

Kristy (Hitchcock)

8 Reviews
0 Upload

24/12/2023

Club wear

This mascara is okay, not the best, but sort of a party mascara. It clumped up quite a bit and started to shed within a few of hours of casual wear. It would work okay for a smokey eye look more so than anything natural. It's definitely a night out at a club, bar, or concert type of mascara.

Khamoshi (Kirkland)

Home Tester Ace
74 Reviews

Khamoshi (Kirkland)

Home Tester Ace
74 Reviews
0 Upload

15/10/2023

Mascara

These multi use mascara is so good and easy to use every day. You can use it three-way, One is to prime the lashes, second one to give you more volume, and the last one is to give you more length and make those eyes pop out.

Frances (Vicksburg)

Home Tester
35 Reviews

Frances (Vicksburg)

Home Tester
35 Reviews
0 Upload

01/04/2023

Not my Go-To

I was excited to try this mascara when I bought it. The packaging reminds me of a marker. But I thought the mascara was just okay. It didn't provide anything different from the average mascara. I've used it twice and it sits in my make-up bag. It actually made my lashes look super thick but clumpy. There's a few others I prefer over this one.

Paige (Pickering)

Home Tester
90 Reviews

Paige (Pickering)

Home Tester
90 Reviews
0 Upload

31/03/2023

Rimmel mascara

I recently tried this Rimmel mascara.I was so impressed of the quality of this product .It did it's job without any smudge or anything.Made my lashes seem fuller .I will definitely be purchasing this product for sure.

Cara (Bay Minette)

Home Tester
36 Reviews

Cara (Bay Minette)

Home Tester
36 Reviews
0 Upload

26/03/2023

Great mascara

I really like this mascara! I was very impressed with how much length and volume this it seemed to give my lashes. I also love that it was easy to get off unlike most mascara’s I’ve used. Over all, I definitely prefer this mascara over the Essence Princess Lash Mascara.

Home Tested with free product

Load more reviews

Rimmel Extra Super Lash Mascara Black