4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag Reviews

Reviews

Gella ()

Home Tester
269 Reviews

Gella

Home Tester
269 Reviews
0 Upload

14/02/2025

Love these

I was pleasantly surprised by this snack, its smooth peanut butter filling and rich chocolate coating create the perfect balance of flavors. The texture is smooth and the taste lingers without being overly sweet. The practical, resealable packaging makes it easy to grab for a quick treat and the portion size strikes a nice balance. It’s a satisfying indulgence that’s become a go-to for me.

Alicia (Bridgewater)

Home Tester Ace
202 Reviews

Alicia (Bridgewater)

Home Tester Ace
202 Reviews
0 Upload

11/02/2025

classic combo: peanut butter & chocolate

This is a classic candy treat that combines the delicious flavors of peanut butter and chocolate. The standup design helps keep the bag upright and the candies from getting crushed.

Sarah ()

Home Tester
154 Reviews

+10

Sarah

Home Tester
154 Reviews
0 Upload

+10

22/01/2025

A holiday favorite

These are a holiday favorite and less messy to just buy than make them.

Joanne (Byron)

5 Reviews

Joanne (Byron)

5 Reviews
0 Upload

06/12/2024

Fanny May—enough said

Fanny May chocolates are a beloved Illinois tradition that never fails to impress. Their products are consistently delicious, and these buckeyes are no exception, offering the perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate that will leave you craving more.

Robert (Naperville)

Home Tester Ace
157 Reviews

Robert (Naperville)

Home Tester Ace
157 Reviews
0 Upload

04/12/2024

A Chicagoland Classic

These are such a tasty treat. If you are from the Chicagoland area, you're likely already very familiar with Fannie May. If not, I highly recommend you trying out their assortment of chocolate treats and other sweet snacks. They have some classic flavors and cookie recipes that will bring a smile to those you share with.

Amanda (Vermilion)

44 Reviews

Amanda (Vermilion)

44 Reviews
0 Upload

20/02/2024

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag are delicious, creamy smooth peanut butter and chocolate goodness , perfect size packet too and the price of it isn't bad either, definitely recommend

Co Kardashian ()

12 Reviews

Co Kardashian ()

12 Reviews
0 Upload

31/08/2023

Cfda program

Howdy seats it's a small world nursery Peprally the blues bb king retro Deere snicker dem franchise boyz Ciara tlc miss mulatto princess nauwisa Disney Kelloggs

()

31 Reviews

31 Reviews
0 Upload

21/05/2023

Found these at Kroger

Oh my goodness I am SO HAPPY to have stumbled across these buckeye chocolates at my local Kroger. I am often craving chocolate and or peanut butter so this is a perfect balance. The buttery peanut butter inside with a more 'solid' piece on top truly adds to the tasteful experience.

Joy (Calumet City)

Home Tester
15 Reviews

Joy (Calumet City)

Home Tester
15 Reviews
0 Upload

14/05/2023

Natural Tasty Treat

Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag has a very refreshing natural peanut butter chocolate taste, smooth creamy texture and I really like that they're individually wrap. The stand-up bag is made for convenient access. Great natural tasty treats to sooth that sweet tooth!

Home Tested with free product

Amber (Johnstown)

Home Tester Ace
19 Reviews

Amber (Johnstown)

Home Tester Ace
19 Reviews
0 Upload

12/04/2023

Pretty Good!

These are super flavorful and creamy. Not as good as homemade buckeyes, and of course I'm biased because I live in Ohio. Still a yummy treat!

Home Tested with free product

Joseph (Wayland)

Home Tester
17 Reviews

Joseph (Wayland)

Home Tester
17 Reviews
0 Upload

07/04/2023

Candy

The best peanut butter buckeye candy ever it just melts in your mouth and rich creamy peanut butter is smooth and I don't think it needs any. Improvements except to have more in the bag

Home Tested with free product

Jackie (Grand Rapids)

Home Tester
18 Reviews

Jackie (Grand Rapids)

Home Tester
18 Reviews
0 Upload

07/04/2023

Creamy and delicious

I really enjoyed the Fannie May Buckeyes, they were creamy and delicious. Perfect for a satisfying sweet tooth moment. Packaged individually, and easy to open.

Home Tested with free product

Rebekah (Bay City)

Home Tester
9 Reviews

Rebekah (Bay City)

Home Tester
9 Reviews
0 Upload

06/04/2023

Sweet treat

Tried Fannie mat peanut butter buckeyes. There were each individually wrapped, making it easy to take one as a treat or pack in your lunch box. Great flavor mix of peanut buttter and chocolate with a smooth finish and taste. just the right size.

Home Tested with free product

Jenny (Oakland County)

Home Tester Ace
39 Reviews

Jenny (Oakland County)

Home Tester Ace
39 Reviews
0 Upload

06/04/2023

Delicious

These were so yummy! The peanut butter inside is so thick and creamy and the outside chocolate shell is so good! I sat here and ate half the bag by myself because they were so good.

Home Tested with free product

Sarah (Bay City)

Home Tester Pro
74 Reviews

Sarah (Bay City)

Home Tester Pro
74 Reviews
0 Upload

06/04/2023

Lacking Peanut Butter Flavor

These left me wanting much more peanut butter. Buckeyes are usually soft and these are not and just felt like an okay representation of this treat.

Home Tested with free product

Load more reviews

4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag